Understand your friend saying some things that you related to in your post wlayton.
First off, HM has the job, don't think it is a case of "beating him out". Coaches have said he is the starter. Would be surprised if those in Athens moved away from their positions of "keeping their word". Maybe at some point the offensive minds will take a long, hard look at what the defensive side is preparing to do. Change for a greater cause.
Like you, I talk with some that seem to think that Faton Bauta is a "brighter, more athletic player" than Hutson Mason. I am told that Hutson Mason does not read as quickly as the more proven quarterbacks. Arm strength, both Bauta and Ramsey have stronger arms.
As to the Tebow comparison, that really made me scratch my head. Your friend is right when he compares Bauta and Tebow running with power. Difference between the two, Bauta has some wiggle along with power, Tebow was power. Bauta faster than Tebow.
Read an article sometime back when AM was still in Athens. He is one of those that said Faton catches on in an instant. Not to be ugly, Tebow was not the brightest bulb on the tree.
Another point from where I sit. If Hutson Mason is somewhat of a clone of David Greene, unless Theus and one or two more fail to show up again, I can see someone at quarterback that has the ability to escape.
As far as experience, Hutson Mason has been an understudy. While he was playing that part, Faton Bauta was taking the second teamers and gaining experience against our first string defense.
Like you said wlayton, much of the above coming from a friend who you respect for his knowledge in football. This is why we discuss things. Playing the quarterback position is one thing, coaching quarterbacks and running an offense differ greatly.
Just thoughts.