I'm so glad you made this post OldSouthDawg. I've been getting annoyed with all the CMR bashing going on in Dawg Nation.
I give CMR an A until '07. He's had to learn on the job from the beginning having no head coaching experience, and he learned this year that sometimes your friend just isn't getting the job done. I think making tough personnel decisions will be easier for him form now on.
IMO, the combination of injuries and still having CWM on the staff ruined '07. This year was the perfect storm of CWM, Joe Cox meltdowns, refs inexplicably calling imaginary penalties (OK State and LSU), and the third toughtest schedule in the country. This year was rough, but I can't see why anyone could realistically think that we'll have any more 5 loss seasons considering CMR's record.
I give CMR an A since Dec 2. He finally fired CWM, and all he's done since then is offer Bud Foster, Chavis, and Smart our DC job: the best guys in college football. From what I've read here and elsewhrere, CMR did everything right with the Kirby Smart situation. He'll continue to pursue the best guys available.