Mentioned earlier in another thread my feelings toward old style football, concerning field position and punting.
Will do the best I can when posting this, won't pull punches.
I am not impressed with Collin Barber. Couple of reasons.
Mark Richt put it perfectly in my way of thinking. Richt said that Collin Barber in practice booms the ball, lots of hang time. Ok, got it. More to game day than punting high and long in practice. That is good, but there is more, as exhibited by Ray Guy.
Over many years have noticed the oohs and aahs coming from the fans in the stadium after one of those 50/60 yard punts with hang time. Great to see that, puts our Special Teams in great position for no return by the opposition.
One of the problems I have with that is this . . . . Collin Barber has basically nothing to do during the week(s) of practice other than to refine his game for the betterment of the entire team.
Do not like his "slow" movements getting the ball into the air. Set up often "stinks".
During his practice times, one would think that Collin Barber would spend more time working on getting the ball to light inside the 5/10/15/20 yard line. Oohs and aahs also can be heard in the stadium when that happens.
Don't go with the idea of having a distance punter and a "pooch" punter. Not saying not having two punters, but good punting teams over the years have a "special" punter than can do both, distance and pooch. SEC over many years has been one of the best in that area of football. However the best ever was Ray Guy, Southern Mississippi. An amazing athlete that took punting seriously.
The first link below is about stats. The next link covers a lot more. Third link speaks for itself.
Punting could very well be the difference in Little Rock this Saturday.
Just expressing my opinion, again. More to football than running backs, quarterbacks and wide receivers. When Collin Barber is on the field, "he is
one of the eleven".
rayguy.net/portfolio/ray-guy-stats/
rayguy.net/