Okay, so the Rose Bowl that should have happened isn't going to happen, but we can certainly speculate about what would have happened.
After watching both games yesterday... my assessment...
Offenses:
QB: Booty is the better QB right now. If Georgia really wants to win an MNC Stafford has to take his game to another level. When everything else is equal the team with the better QB usually wins.
RB: USC has superior depth, but Brown and Moreno are as good as anything USC puts on the field. Unless either B or M gets injured this is a wash.
Receivers: Mass, Bailey, and Chandler are good. But USC has a whole mess of NFL talent at receiver. USC has the edge here.
O-Line: Stacy Searels has done a masterful job with a young o-line this year. Seriously, this could have been a huge advantage for USC. Instead it is a wash.
Defense:
D-line: UGA's d-line is big, strong, and fast, and as good as anyone in the country. They pounded two future first round draft picks (and Heisman winner) into the freaking turf. What's more, they pretty much forced my beloved Cowboys into a QB change (which, as it turns out, was for the better, though it cost us the game at Troy). I think Georgia's d-line is among the very best in the country.
Linebackers: USC has a future NFL Hall of Famer at linebacker. That alone gives them the edge.
Secondary: UGA's secondary gave up, what, 3 yards total after the catch yesterday? Dawgs have the edge here.
Special teams: USC has a slight edge in speed on special teams, but probably not enough to make a difference.
Coaching: Pete Carroll isn't quite the coaching god that the media makes him out to be. But he is definitely one of the best in the college game. I truly believe HCMR will win an MNC, maybe pretty dawg-gone soon. But until he does you have to give the edge to the man who has won two (even if one was anointed by the media).
GATA! Woof!